It’s not as popular a sentiment as it used to be. Or at least it seems that way. That is, the idea that our salvation is a matter of outweighing our bad deeds with good ones. Kind of like a works-based Gospel meets karma. Or something like that. But nevertheless, it is still an idea that has a way of prevailing. And at first, it makes sense. After all, that is how we operate.
We often assess people or things by their greatest good, and neglect their evil, provided it’s to a lesser degree. Or vice-versa. In a spiritual sense, deed-counting seems like a reasonable approach.
Of course a careful rational exploration of what God must be like will reveal that keeping the works in balance probably wouldn’t get you anywhere with a true deity of cosmic proportion—at least not one that is hands-on. And, the Bible flat out tells us that this isn’t the case. However, the Bible also leaves other clues that this couldn’t possibly be the case. Even if we were somehow misunderstanding what is meant when it tells us that our Life is not based on “works” but on “grace”.
The clues lie in the bible’s teaching that all of man’s works are flawed. Our good deeds aren’t good per se. They are good, in one sense, that all things that hold some reflection of God’s character are good. But they are not “good” in a different sense that nothing is so unless it comes from faith.
The bible teaches that “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin.” (Romans 14:23). It also teaches that before we are made alive through Christ, we are “dead” in our trespasses (Colossians 2:13).
Before being redeemed by Christ, a persons ‘good deeds’ are in their greater part not good deeds. They have the appearance of good deeds, and in a way they are good because they are a reflection of God’s character, but they are still bad deeds.
If our salvation were a matter of balancing the scales, we would never pull it off regardless of how many we manage to perform. For every good deed we do, we not only add weight to the good side of the scale, we add even more weight to the bad side. It would never balance out and we would invariably perish in our sin, thinking to ourselves, “but I’ve been so good!” And our final prideful declaration would dot the T’s and cross the I’s of our well veiled life of sin.
So much for Christian Karma. Thank God for grace.