I’m not a parent. I can only speculate on the best ways to raise children to be productive and self-sufficient people. But as I was discussing similar matters with a friend the other evening when this thought crossed my mind.
“if children are not given some level of independence, they’ll either take it by force or never learn to want it.”
Having done quite a bit of youth ministry, I’m relatively familiar with kids’, namely teenagers’, hang-ups and tendencies. From what I have observed, kids who’s parents hover over them, or fail to give them privacy and independence, seem to cope with it in one of two ways.
First, they may be rebellious. In spite of their parent’s best attempts to protect them from social and emotional danger, the kids find a way to defy their parent’s grasp. From my experience, what usually happens is parents end up trying to tighten the reins, which almost always has the effect of further dividing the parties and ultimately diminishing the parent’s meaningful influence in their kid’s lives.
Or, the alternative seems to be that the kids have difficulty thinking for themselves. For example, a sixteen year old kid probably shouldn’t have to ask their parents if it’s okay to see a particular movie in the theaters—or in a friend’s living room for that matter. Rather, by that time, they ought to be able to have the good judgment to know whether it was a good idea in the first place.
Now, of course, all this is speculation based on a fleeting thought I had. It seems pretty accurate to me from what I’ve seen. But what do you think? What roll does independence play in a child’s development?

